Compare and contrast the experience with the mother carrying her nearly dead child, and the dog in the hut. What do these two experiences begin to show us about human nature, and the nature of existence? What do we learn from watching the priest react to each? And finally, what way can this be seen as a hopeful message?
The mother carrying her dead child and the dog in the hut are both very symbolistic parts of The Power and The Glory, in the sense that they carry great meaning, by showing common human nature. The first, the old dog, barely alive, but struggling to survive, is a good example of the priest's situation. He is constantly trying to stay alive, by whatever means possible. When he meets the dog, and notices the bone underneath its paws, he wants it right away. “This was human dignity disputing with a bitch over a bone.” (Page 144)This is his human side, arguing with an animal side, of an argument between desire, and dignity. Instead of waiting, or trying to find something else, he immediately pokes the dog with a wire, and gets the bone. He eats it, and tells himself that he will give a little meat back to the dog. However, he soon devours it, and tosses the picked-clean bone back to the dog, somewhat guilty. This whole part of Chapter Four tells us of an animal side all humans have, one that can be pushed to greater lengths than what we normally are. While the priest isn't going too far, he still eats the whole bone without noticing, and guiltily gives the bone back, somewhat regretful, but accepting the fact his life is above that of a dog, the food chain in effect.
The mother carrying her child is again, another part in our nature, the more spiritual part of us. The mother insists on taking her child to a burial ground; the priest thinks it to be easier to simply bury it in the village. However, the mother stays true to tradition, and, regardless of whether or not the priest would have gone with her, have left to the burial ground. When the mother left leaving a sugar ball to the child, the priest once again, out of desperation, took the ball. This is the same animal nature, the one witnessed with the dog. He soon crossed the border, and when a man with a gun comes to him, he has no intent of continuing his journey, and tells his true name. Oddly enough, the man was happy to see a priest. He is given a sense of hope, although he doesn't directly acknowledge it, and gives a hopeful message to the novel.
When the priest enters the village, after leaving the dog, he felt as though he was in limbo, a state that is described as between worlds, in and out of consciousness. This represents the space in between Heaven and Hell, where the people with no conviction lie. The priest does nothing for others, and does nothing for himself besides what he needs, therefore erasing any sort of conviction he has at this point, which in turn, erases his hope, leading up to the border, and giving his identity to the man. At this point, the priest somewhat forgets what he is living for, his nature of existence. Also, everything he does in this part is half, he can only communicate with the woman in half Spanish, half English. The child and dog are half dead when he finds them, the shelter in the village is only half a hut. This all represents his state of limbo, half in consciousness, half out of it. The two events of Chapter Four, and the symbolism in between, all represent a crucial part of human nature, one that comes out of its shadow when we are in hard-pressed times, forced to survive by any way possible.
It is far better to grasp the universe as it really is than to persist in delusion, however satisfying and reassuring. -Carl Sagan
Times change, worlds change, but people, people never change.
What had started as an arduous project is now one of my passions. I love to write; this is where I try to paint pictures--with words. I'm a sophomore in high school, if you're wondering.
Need to contact me for some reason? My email is dsrandhawa3244@gmail.com.
Posted by
Dilpreet
1 comments:
This is an excellent response. The introduction handles the question well, and connects to the thesis. Then the next paragraphs tackle text evidence to build your solid response, and finally, your conclusion brings things together with an original, and fresh concept, the notion of things in halves. Very cool! I really enjoyed this response, and continue to be impressed with your improvement. Excellent job.
Post a Comment